The boss of Sanzaar, Andy Marinos, continues to defend the format of Super 18 despite the massive and constant criticism of how complex and unfair the system patently is – to everyone except Andy it seems.
New Zealand – the union, franchises and media have been particularly vociferous in their demands for change which is not that surprising –
New Zealand won’t give up its efforts to force a change to next year’s Super Rugby playoff format, but the union is resigned to the prospect of the status quo.
The expanded competition has multiple flaws but the most glaring surfaced at the business end this year when the Chiefs and High-landers were forced to play away quarter-finals against sides who gathered fewer competition points.
There were knock-on effects of the contrived format felt by the Crusaders, who had to wait an eternity to discover where they would play their quarter-final and were then left stranded in Christchurch for two days, waiting for flights to South Africa.
Whilst there are some reservations in Australia and South Africa they are less keen to ditch a structure that does favour their teams –
All five New Zealand teams campaigned for the introduction of a straight top eight next year – where the four teams with the most points, regardless of where they are based, host quarter-finals. But that proposal has been rejected by the South Africans and Australians who want the continuation of a guaranteed home playoff spot for the respective winners of each of the four conferences.
Well – they would wouldn’t they!
According to reports –
Marinos’ personal market research tells him the competition is flawed. He’s had that reinforced in his travels through the foundation countries but says those viewpoints are not right.
http://m.nzherald.co.nz/rugby/news/article.cfm?c_id=80&objectid=11715490
This may of course be because his job depends on Super Rugby and why he is still trying to expand the format to include North America.
Eddie Jones contended last week that NZ control rugby – if he’s right, and I think he probably is, then I expect Super rugby in the current format to change for the 2018 season.
Eddie Jones: Do New Zealand run world rugby?
It would be a good idea if they had a word with Sean Fitzpatrick and his idea for a two tier structure.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=11713138